Jan. 3, 1969: Starrwriter 69

Quite literally, the freshest sound in music right now is by Ringo Starr, whose 17th solo release — Ringo 2012 — hit shelves and servers today (Jan. 31, 2012).  Most of the songs are at least co-written by him, meaning perhaps Richard Starkey is is finally hitting his stride as a songwriter as he has little more than 100 songs to his credit over the course of 50-plus years since the Beatles began recording. And many of those — while I don’t doubt his contributions — are things like “Dig It” and “Flying,” songs that received the four-Beatle credit and other songs in which he presumably didn’t have much heavy lifting.

Of course, that list doesn’t count songs written and not registered. It certainly doesn’t have songs he partially crafted. And that’s just what we have out of Ringo as early on the second day as rehearsals continue at Twickenham.

Source: thebeatles.com

George was discussing The Band with Paul and Ringo (John wasn’t there yet) and how their favorite track (presumably off the White Album — he didn’t specify) was “Don’t Pass Me By” because of its country western vibe.  “That’s their scene, completely,” George said of the very first composition credited solely to Starkey.

Paul chimes in to ask Ringo, “Are you going to write another?”

“Yes I am,” he replied, almost incredulously before some cross-talk obscures what was said next, although Paul already knew what was in the works. In fact, he already was able to name one — “Picasso” (also bootlegged as “I Bought A Picasso”) — before Ringo started pounding out the chords (a struggle).

“Let’s hear it,” Paul asked, remarking it was “a fast one” — something they were looking to add to the set list of the live show. “Too fast for me,” Ringo replied. Paul, as well as George, had absolutely heard it before based on their reactions and subsequent suggestions.

Sounding very similar — and, really, quite like a sped-up “Don’t Pass Me By” — Ringo then launched into “Taking a Trip to Carolina” — a song he’d first touched upon for 45 seconds or so a few minutes prior to “Picasso.” As he says midway through, “the words are not very good.”

Note that this clip, from the bonus disc that came with “Let it Be … Naked,” begins with the exchange that preceded “Picasso” edited in as the lead-in to “Taking a Trip to Carolina.” But in reality, that’s not the exact order of how it really happened.

“Carolina” was also featured in the 2021 Get Back docuseries.

Ringo wouldn’t showcase a song again until later in the month, with “Octopus’s Garden,” which of course would later appear on Abbey Road (I’ll cover the song’s introduction to the sessions when I reach that date). We wouldn’t hear either “Picasso” or “Taking a Trip to Carolina” for the remainder of the tapes.

He would not have a vocal on Let it Be — either of the iterations (Glyn Johns mix of the Get Back LP or the final Phil Spector production) — marking the first time that happened since the A Hard Day’s Night LP in 1964 (*He didn’t have a lead on ’67’s Magical Mystery Tour, either, but it was technically an EP with old singles padding the US full-album release).


Filed under Day by day

16 responses to “Jan. 3, 1969: Starrwriter 69

  1. Thanks!… listening to your clips here and the Winter of Discontent podcast for Day 2 Jan. 3… it’s clear that Peter Jackson’s Get Back really distorts the interactions between the Beatles. Jackson took a clip of George saying how he has quiet songs, and inserts this clip seamlessly into the part just before Ringo says he has his song Taking a trip to Carolina… and not only does Jackson reverse the order of these two parts, but he makes it looks like Ringo cuts off George to talk about his Trip to Carolina song just when George was talking about his slow songs. He covers his track with editing to make it look like this is the reality. For anyone interested in the chemistry of the the Beatles, Peter Jackson’s doc is really not trust worthy. He just has no shame about taking these little liberties and trying to make it look like fact. It’s one thing combining video to the tapes to fill things in, but reversing order creating fake sequences…. move over Winston Smith.


  2. Pingback: TMBP Extra: Leave me waiting here | They May Be Parted

  3. Pingback: Jan. 6: That weight and this boy | They May Be Parted

  4. Pingback: TMBP Extra: Jan. 3, 1969 recap | They May Be Parted

  5. Pingback: Jan. 3: Et cetera | They May Be Parted

  6. Pingback: Jan. 3: Fifteen minutes of fame | They May Be Parted

  7. Pingback: TMBP Extra: Oh what joy | They May Be Parted

  8. Pingback: Jan. 6: That weight and this boy | They May Be Parted

  9. Pingback: TMBP Extra: Jan. 3, 1969 recap | They May Be Parted

  10. Bart M

    Excellent post. I’ve recently spent a lot of time on these songs and I have discovered that every take of Carolina came after Picasso. Having acquired all the relevant tracks from the A/B Road bootleg (disc for 3 January), I realized that all the parts of a continuous series are represented but they’re either not consecutive or separated by irrelevant tracks. The correct order is the following:

    1. Picasso 3:23
    2. Taking A Trip To Carolina 3:25
    3. Taking A Trip To Carolina 3:26
    4. Taking A Trip To Carolina 3:17
    5. Unknown 3,18

    When placed end to end there are no gaps or skips between them: they make one continuous recording. (I’ve also combined them in Audacity to make a single track, and it required not editing whatsoever)

    Note that the last track has no vocals, but it is clearly Ringo at the piano playing Carolina for a minute or two before stopping and picking up with what sounds like random doodling.

    Note also that even before placing Carolina after Picasso, it became obvious to me that that had to be the correct order because of the way all three Beatles crack up when Ringo sings “Ob Baby”. The reason is he had used the same phrase already when he tried out Picasso, so when he uses it again on Carolina, they all laugh.


    • Dan

      Bart – Amazing work and insight. I’m going to have to go back and do that same reordering. I always figured there was more to that laugh!

      And thanks for being here!


      • Anonymous

        You’re welcome! I’d be happy to forward the Mp3’s of my edits to you if you trust content from a complete stranger!


  11. Pingback: Jan. 3: Et cetera | They May Be Parted

  12. Pingback: Jan. 3: Fifteen minutes of fame | They May Be Parted

  13. Craig

    Always loved this song! There’s something to it, very catchy. I wish they’d given it a chance and that the others had helped Ringo flesh this tune out so that it could be recorded properly. Then again, I’m almost surprised this :25 second clip of “Carolina” wasn’t included on ‘Let it Be’ ala the way “Take Me Back” was included on ‘The Beatles’. Great little ditty by Ringo.


    • Dan

      Interesting thought, and I agree, could have been a nice jumpy number to cut the mood a bit on the record. I bet it never even got on either of the producers’ radars (either Johns or Spector) was because it was only performed this one time at Twickenham and only while the cameras’ audio rolled, not in the actual recording studio after they moved to Saville Row. So it wasn’t even an option in their hands to splice in even this segment. Spector probably didn’t even know it existed (though Johns should have, having been around Twickenham).


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s